Writer’s Movie Review: Catching Fire


Posted On Dec 1 2013 by

20131201-174919.jpg

Catching Fire, the second part to The Hunger Games trilogy, opened last week just in time for the big Thanksgiving movie rush. Of particular interest to writers is the big question of how to treat the middle part of a trilolgy. While not the focus here, I apply two basic rules when it comes to trilogies:

1. Each book should stand alone. It should have it’s own beginning, middle, and end with a resolution to the current story.

2. The first and second books should leave open only the minor questions. In the case of Hunger Games, we were left with Haymitch’s warning to Katniss that the Capital would not be pleased with her act of rebellion. If Collin’s had chosen not to write the next book, we would not have been dissapointed. She wrote that warning to give us just enough of a teaser to want to pick up the second book. In the case of Catching Fire, the open issues were larger. At this point the author has committed herself to writing all three, because we would not be satisfied with that ending. The Empire Strikes Back ended almost identically. Like Collins, though, George Lucas knew by this point that he had a hit and had committed himself to the third part.

That should be a good takeaway for novice authors. If you have a trilogy in mind, make sure that first book can stand on its own. That way, if a publisher tells you it didn’t have enough sales to continue, you can drop the project without ticking off too many of your new fans. If a publisher commits to part 2, you can be feel pretty safe in assuming part 3 will be picked up as well, so you have more freedom to leave more open questions at the end of part 2.

Okay? That’s all I’ll say on the issue of the trilogy. I plan on taking this same route, but book one of my trilogy is being plotted as if I will never follow up with a second part. It’s just the safe way to proceed.

Catching Fire

Onto Catching Fire. As promised, I want to break down the film to its major story elements, which should be nearly identical to what Collin’s did in the novel and what we should do in our novels.

Spoiler alert. I give away the ending, so here’s your chance to stop and come back after seeing the film!

Inciting incident. Troops in the village. We’re given a hint that something is amiss when extra troops and a new (and nasty) head peacekeeper shows up. The capstone is when President Snow shows up in Katniss’ home to give her a not-so-veiled threat to make sure her love story is convincing and that it’s up to her to restrain the uprising in the districts.

Set-up. Katniss and Peeta go on tour and we see that their lives are not their own. They must continue to play this game forever. We’re also given more foreshadowing of the rebellion brewing in the districts.

Plot point 1 or point of no return. The quarter quell is announced. Katniss and Peeta are to return to the games.

Mid-point. While there was no point of deep reflection, I’m going to call it at the time when Haymitch tells Katniss to “remember who the enemy is” while she’s in the arena. Clearly, he’s telling her that she needs to look outward, toward the evil capital, and not just focus on killing off her fellow tributes. By the way, this also serves as the log line or “theme stated,” though I’d like to see the theme stated earlier, as near the beginning as possible.

Plot point 2. This came a little late I think, past the 75% mark as is standard. Katniss is attacked by an ally, Johanna Mason. Katniss is suddenly alone and uncertain who she can trust. All this happens as her team is setting up a major booby trap for the career tributes.

Dark night of the soul. Katniss hits bottom immediately. She goes back to the lightning tree to find Peeta gone and another ally unconcious. She believes she’s been betrayed and is alone. All is lost.

Climax. Katniss realizes what the game plan is, to defeat the game maker and the capital. She risks her own life to take down the force field surrounding the arena.

Final scene. Katniss is airlifted out in a hovercraft, only to discover that it’s actually part of the rebellion. The game maker is part of the rebel force and she’s being whisked off to District 13. The fate of Peeta is unknown and District 12 has been blown off the map. Again, major questions are left unresolved, much different than the first book and movie of the trilogy. But note the similarities between this ending and the last scene of The Empire Strikes Back. You know you’ll be back for part three, and so does the author.

What could have been better

I felt through both the novels and films that Katniss had a flat character arc. While outwardly she makes the right choices to defeat the enemy, inwardly she shows little change. This becomes even more apparent in the third book of the trilogy, where Katniss should undergo a huge change from the opening of the first book. I believe that is the primary reason Mockinjay got mixed reviews. She begins the series as a dark character only interested in survival and, it seems to me, that’s how she ends the series. I understand that Hollywood is splitting the last book into two movies. This is one of those rare times when I hope they make some major changes and improve the story.

These are the major points we should watch for when we view a movie. We should also look for foreshadowing, symbolism, the “save the cat” moment to build audience empathy with the protogaonist, and other tricks of the trade. I highly recommend you read Save the Cat. By understanding the screenwriters process, you have a better chance of breaking down the structure of a film and transferring that knowledge to your own writing.

How about you? What did you take away from the film that may help in your own writing process?

RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
Facebook
Google+
http://ronestradabooks.com/2013/12/01/writers-movie-review-catching-fire/
Instagram

Last Updated on: December 2nd, 2013 at 7:02 am, by Ron


Written by Ron

Just about everything I believe has been shaped by the written word. But books don't force a belief; they stir the imagination so that you, the reader, eventually draw your own conclusions. We grow richer in spirit when we read, deeper in our understanding of the universe and our role in it. That's why I read. That's why I write. To offer you a bit of myself. Come along on my journey, won't you? There's plenty of room.


2 responses to “Writer’s Movie Review: Catching Fire

  1. I like your story arc analysis and though I didn’t read the book, I enjoyed the movie. Except for the ending. I was actually quite peeved that they left such a big tread hanging. I actually had no idea the movie was over when it was. I wanted more resolution, or maybe a glimpse of Peeta in the new environment, IDK, something that didn’t make me feel like I was hanging. Maybe a foreshadowing of what was to come. I guess that’s something to look for in our stories, eh? What I took away was more ideas for our YA dystopia series! 🙂

  2. I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this web site. I’m hoping the same high-grade website post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing skills has encouraged me to get my own blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a great example of it.